Sleepwalking Into Prohibition: Notes on The Sex Myth

I loved the Belle de Jour books and have just got round to reading The Sex Myth, Brooke Magnanti‘s non fiction critique of contemporary attitudes on sexuality. As you’ll see I disagree with many of her conclusions, but the book is fascinating and beautifully written and, on many big questions, she gets it right. We haven’t totally outgrown Victorian puritanism and morbid assumptions – one example, particularly annoying for me, is the convention that men are only interested in getting laid, while women only submit to the whole beastly business because it allows them to start a family. There is the elitist view, also shared by the Victorians, that the masses can’t ‘handle’ erotica and need to be protected from it, just as they need to be protected from alcohol and tobacco.

Finally Magnanti discusses The Handmaid’s Tale, Margaret Atwood’s novel of puritan totalitarianism. In her novel Atwood explores the convergence between religious fundamentalist and rad-fem politics and, as Magnanti explains, ‘People in the middle, who had no particular investment or opinion either way, got caught in the resulting military dictatorship.’ It’s a powerful study about the unforeseen consequences of political activism, the unconscious enabling of authority and power, the way that people, with the best possible intentions, can sleepwalk into totalitarianism. Be careful what you wish for, Atwood says. It’s something many people have either forgotten or never learned, but Dr Magnanti’s book is also in its way a testament to Atwood’s warning.

Update: Michael Ezra has picked me up on a point.

Also, in articles, here’s my recent piece on the new Raymond Chandler bio.


One Response to “Sleepwalking Into Prohibition: Notes on The Sex Myth”

  1. KMathers Says:

    I’m sorry, Magnanti can’t even interpret The Handmaid’s Tale correctly–that is, without the blinders of her own agenda. Really, skewing Atwood’s depiction of prostitution as the low bar for women’s existence, as some kind of “See? Prostitution is a valid choice!” attempt at validation? Magnanti does the same with much of the research she quotes. For an author who loves to hype up supposed conspiratorial agendas, she sure knows how to shove some of her own. You don’t need religious dogma or money to be self-serving.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: