Does God Hate Women?

bensonDisclaimer – one of this book’s co-authors, Ophelia Benson, is my editor at Butterflies and Wheels

This is a terrible book. It’s a catalogue of cruelty, evil and despair. The first thirty pages comprise case studies of faith-based oppression – stories from women in Pakistan and Saudi Arabia and Nigeria, stories of women being raped and flogged and mutilated, stories of those who die and are forgotten. This is not the worst example but it will serve for all:

In a macabre inversion of the usual pattern of human valour which sees people rushing into a burning building to rescue survivors, the girls at this school were sent back into the smoke and flames after they had already managed to escape. The reason for this was that the Saudi religious police, who had turned up outside the school, considered the girls to be inappropriately dressed for an escape – apparently they had neglected to put on their abayas (enveloping black head-to-toe robes) before running for their lives.  

At the core of monotheistic religion is an obsession with, and corresponding fear of, women and sex – the Other. The crimes committed against half the human race by religious governments and movements are protected by the Big Lie – that faith is centrally about love and compassion, and wickedness done in the name of religion is merely a perversion of peaceful scripture. Ophelia Benson and Jeremy Stangroom take this further. The point is that God can’t tell you what he wants. There’s no higher authority that can rule out faith-based persecution of women. This alone is why religion deserves no respect from anyone with pretensions to decency and morality. 

It may not surprise you to know that the usual cliches of ‘shrill’ and ‘strident’ thrown about by religious apologists bear no relation to the actual tone of the book, which is calm and measured despite the horrors of its subject matter. What Benson and Stangroom call the woman’s ‘ability to refuse’ is a relatively new thing. We live in a sexual marketplace where women are free to deny sex to men, whereas in most of the world and for most of human history the woman has been entirely subservient to her father and then to her husband: ‘honour is between the legs of women’.

It’s at times like this that I think anyone who believes that progress is a myth needs their rationality called into question. Of course, the authors point out, ‘the ability to refuse means that some people will be disappointed’; personally, this is how I account for the enthusiasm for theocracy among Western males. 

This book is terrible but essential. Ignoring it is not an option.

Advertisements

9 Responses to “Does God Hate Women?”

  1. saeed Says:

    I take it you and benson are fans of ayaan hersi ali?????????

  2. saeed Says:

    …also have you ever thought why middle class white people like you and benson fixiate on hersi ali when there are many other somali womens groups in your own city manchester and in somalia/land who never get any coverage by the pro-lib left…

  3. maxdunbar Says:

    Hi Saeed

    The book discusses Hirsi Ali among women from various Muslim backgrounds including Somalian.

    Have you read it?

    Also – and I’ve said this before – if any of your friends in Manchester’s Somali community want to give me feedback on this blog they are welcome to do so on max.dunbar@gmail.com

  4. saeed Says:

    Yeah have read it…if what she says is true then i feel sorry for her…but as ian buruma says any criticism of hersi ali is taken, by neo-cons and sections of the left (i.e.) paul berman, as an attack on women’s rights which is an absurd reaction….

    any way i will repeat my question why do benson and people like yourself fixate on hersi ali???? there are a myriad of somali women’s groups/feminists in the west and somali/land????

    so why do they not get any coverage?…..before you answer just ask yourself that question.

  5. maxdunbar Says:

    I haven’t mentioned Hirsi Ali in this piece.

    I think it’s you that has the fixation.

  6. saeed Says:

    apologies if i come over as a bit rude…it was not my intention to offend you…am just interested to see why hersi ali gets so much media coverage and other muslim women don’t?

  7. maxdunbar Says:

    Don’t worry, it takes a lot to offend me.

    I’m not sure why Hirsi Ali gets more coverage than others. I suppose it’s because she’s an ex politician with a couple of books in print.

  8. Cohen Tells How « Max Dunbar Says:

    […] property, the presenter told her she was an ‘extremist’. With dreary inevitability, Does God Hate Women’s critics say that Benson and Stangroom’s atheist liberalism is as fundamentalist as […]

  9. Cohen Tells How « Shiraz Socialist Says:

    […] property, the presenter told her she was an ‘extremist’. With dreary inevitability, Does God Hate Women’s critics say that Benson and Stangroom’s atheist liberalism is as fundamentalist as […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: